Broken Soul (https://www.fanfiction.net/s/8182175/1/Broken-Soul) by alxm: "The brothers have been separated for six months, unbeknownst to Dean that in all those months, his little brother was being held captive by a group hunters and tortured severely every day. When he finds that out, he goes for his rescue. And when he finally finds him again, he doesn't like what the months of abuse has done to his baby brother." (gen; a whole slew of warnings including graphic torture and rape)
The World Devours Me (http://varkelton.livejournal.com/45647.html) by varkelton: "Dean thought he was doing the right thing when he let Sam walk away from hunting.....away from him. Sam thought the separation was nothing more than he deserved. They both thought Castiel had found a way to keep Lucifer from finding them. Neither one of them knew how wrong they really were." (Sam/Dean; the hunter bit is in the beginning but the whole story's full of hurt!Sam; heed the warnings on this one, seriously)
Vengeance (http://ncc1701a.livejournal.com/22312.html) by ncc1701a: "John, Dean and Sam get kidnapped from hunters who have a grudge against John. There was this hunt a few years back where John withheld some information and people got hurt. Now they have the Winchesters and they want to play a game because how do you hurt John Winchester? Yes, hurt his sons! The rules of the game: John has to pull a piece of paper from a bag, he has to read out loud what stands on it and then he has to decide who of his sons has to endure what is written on it. After one of the men carried out the instructions on either Dean or Sam, it all starts again. If John doesn't choose they threaten to shoot both Dean and Sam. Instructions on the papers: methods of torture (like whipping, branding, electrocution, bastinado) or humiliating acts (like stripping in front of the hunters, giving one of the men a blowjob). (I want both boys over eighteen and hurt but I would like if Dean bears the brunt of it, John choosing him more often, Dean pleading with John to pick him)." (gen; again, lots of warnings)
Pray for Us Sinners (http://kaasknot.livejournal.com/9376.html) by kaasknot: "Sam and Dean get kidnapped, and are then tortured by a variety of BDSM kinks." (Sam/Dean; possible triggers should be pretty obvious from the summary)
If you haven't read the Freak Camp Verse (http://archiveofourown.org/series/5884), I highly recommend it. It's an AU with unrelated Sam/Dean and TONS of hurt!Sam at the hands of hunters. Warnings are pretty spelled out in the tags.
Idiot's Paradise (https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5409251/1/Idiots_Paradise) by phx: "Dean IS happy. He is. Until Rufus calls... AU Tag for 5.03." (gen)
Thirty Minutes (http://vail-kagami.livejournal.com/136953.html) by vail_kagami: "There are still hunters out there who don't like Sam very much." (gen; complete lack of a happy ending)
no subject
The World Devours Me (http://varkelton.livejournal.com/45647.html) by varkelton: "Dean thought he was doing the right thing when he let Sam walk away from hunting.....away from him. Sam thought the separation was nothing more than he deserved. They both thought Castiel had found a way to keep Lucifer from finding them. Neither one of them knew how wrong they really were." (Sam/Dean; the hunter bit is in the beginning but the whole story's full of hurt!Sam; heed the warnings on this one, seriously)
Vengeance (http://ncc1701a.livejournal.com/22312.html) by ncc1701a: "John, Dean and Sam get kidnapped from hunters who have a grudge against John. There was this hunt a few years back where John withheld some information and people got hurt. Now they have the Winchesters and they want to play a game because how do you hurt John Winchester? Yes, hurt his sons! The rules of the game: John has to pull a piece of paper from a bag, he has to read out loud what stands on it and then he has to decide who of his sons has to endure what is written on it. After one of the men carried out the instructions on either Dean or Sam, it all starts again. If John doesn't choose they threaten to shoot both Dean and Sam. Instructions on the papers: methods of torture (like whipping, branding, electrocution, bastinado) or humiliating acts (like stripping in front of the hunters, giving one of the men a blowjob). (I want both boys over eighteen and hurt but I would like if Dean bears the brunt of it, John choosing him more often, Dean pleading with John to pick him)." (gen; again, lots of warnings)
Pray for Us Sinners (http://kaasknot.livejournal.com/9376.html) by kaasknot: "Sam and Dean get kidnapped, and are then tortured by a variety of BDSM kinks." (Sam/Dean; possible triggers should be pretty obvious from the summary)
If you haven't read the Freak Camp Verse (http://archiveofourown.org/series/5884), I highly recommend it. It's an AU with unrelated Sam/Dean and TONS of hurt!Sam at the hands of hunters. Warnings are pretty spelled out in the tags.
Idiot's Paradise (https://www.fanfiction.net/s/5409251/1/Idiots_Paradise) by phx: "Dean IS happy. He is. Until Rufus calls... AU Tag for 5.03." (gen)
Thirty Minutes (http://vail-kagami.livejournal.com/136953.html) by vail_kagami: "There are still hunters out there who don't like Sam very much." (gen; complete lack of a happy ending)