First Time Wincest Creature Fics

Hi, I actually haven't come across many creature fics in this fandom - I will be looking at the tags here later - and I was hoping you all would rec me some of your favorites. My only requirements are that the fics are first time wincest and complete, or if not complete then still being updated regularly. I would also love to read some fics in which the boys somehow end up in a threesome with a woman and realize that they're more into each other than they are into her. Pretend couple. fuck or die, and cursed fics are always awesome, too. Domestic fics in which the boys still hunt or still help other hunters are great too. I also have a huge jealousy/possessiveness kink. Once again, only first times that are either complete or regularly updated, please. And no AUs! Thanks for your help!

People Assume the Boys Are a Couple

So everybody knows how the brothers often get mistaken for lovers in canon, right? I'd really like to see a fic where that happens with John around. I've never seen that before but I think it would be really interesting! I don't care if its gen or if there is wincest going on, its all good with me. Hope someone can help!

Wincest Fics

Hi, I'm having a hard time lately finding long complete first time non-au Wincest recs rated nc-17 that I haven't already read, and I was hoping you guys could help me out some. I've been going through the tags here, and I've read pretty much everything at the Sam/Dean slash archive. So I was hoping maybe ya'll might have some recs of good fics that just aren't as widely known. I was also hoping that anyone with downloads to stories (that the author gave permission to give out, of course) that match this request will send them to me. Just let me know if you have one or more and I'll give you my email. Also if you know of any other communities that would be great too. Thank you guys a lot!

Specific Stanford-era Fic

So, I'm slowly driving myself out of my mind trying to find this fic. Because of my scattered way of browsing LJ, there's really no telling how I found it in the first place, so I can't find it for the life of me.

It was a oneshot Sam/Jess fic, with porny goodness; Jess is giving Sam a blowjob (I'm fairly sure), and she starts to ask Sam about if he's ever thought about it, if he ever imagined himself with a guy, etc. Sam's really hesitant at first, but eventually starts really getting into it and talking about this guy that he was crushing on all throughout his teenage years, and at one point I remember him saying that he used to lie in the bed across from said mystery man wishing that he would just get into Sam's bed and "take what was his". Eventually, it comes out that Sam's old crush is his brother, and at some point during his blissed-out-blab-session, Sam switched from the past tense "wishing my brother was fucking me then" to "wish my brother was fucking me now" and I'm pretty sure Jess didn't feel any sort of judgmental about Sam's feelings for Dean.

Seriously, if anybody knows what I'm talking about, I will actually love you forever.

Soulless!Sam, wincest/ Dark angel

I was just wondering if there are any fics out there of soulless Sam pining over or being really possessive of Dean? I'd prefer for it to be consensual but dub-con is al-right to!

I also just recently got into Dark angel and was wondering if anyone could find me some Dean/Alec or Ben crossover fics aswell.
Thank you!

specific fic- Sam's birthday

Hi guys!
I am searching for a specific Sam/Dean fic. It was not an AU as far as I remember. Sam was still in high school, though, so it is a pre-series fic. Sam and Dean were living at Bobby's , and John was away on a hunt. The only thing I remember clearly was a scene of Dean and Sam in the kitchen kissing after a long UST buildup. It was Sam's birthday. A cake of sorts was involved. And a trip to a town, like a date maybe?
I know it's not a lot to go by, but can you guys please, help me find it?
Thank you!

Borderline Non-Con

I'm looking for stories where Sam is sort of obsessed with Dean as in an unrequited, more than a brother love, kind of thing that eventually escalates to borderline non-con. Like he sort of can't stop himself but Dean is definitely not interested and stays that way and wants him to stop. I read Unholy by Isolde13 on ff.net and that story was almost perfect. I especially like how Sam was slipping sleeping pills into Dean's drink so he could indulge himself at night with out Dean knowing at all. Kudos if you could find stories with those sort of elements. Or just stories were Sam rugs Dean with out his consent period, come to think of it

I'm really looking for stories where Dean is solidly not interested and Sam can not reconcile himself to silently pining and eventually (intentional or not) acts on it.

Pre-series fics are fine too.

Looking for steamy first time Wincest or J2

Hi, I'm looking for some seriously hot and sexy stories featuring either Dean/Sam or Jared/Jenson.First times only, please. I don't care what length it is as long as it's hot and has at least a little plot telling how the pairing got together. Please rec me your favorites? Thanks!

Looking for a specific type of Wincest story ...

Please only first time fics with smut! I want stories where one or both the boys read the slash about themselves and realize that it's exactly what they want. Thanks!

Looking for certain types of Wincest recs ...

Hi, could ya'll please rec me some smutty, complete, first time fics that include one or more of the following:

1) AU after a specific episode
2) Pretend Couple
3) Fuck or Die
4) Case
5) Humor
6) Drama
7) Romance
8) Slow build up to relationship
9) Boys have Powers or become Creatures o
10) Hurt Comfort
11) Jealousy, Protectiveness, and or Possessiveness
12) Connected Boys
13) Horror

Please rec me everything you think of! Thanks!

Request for Missouri fics (FOUND)

I've never read anything specifically like this, as there seems to be a sad and distinct lack of Missouri Mosely in SPN fandom. But I'd love to read something, anything, that involves her as a main character, and I know, I know, this may be too much to ask, but something where she knows about the Sam/Dean thing? Before it happens, or while it's happening, either way, I don't care.

Even without that, anything that highlights her relationship with the brothers would be VERY appreciated. Thanks!

Edit - So many great recs here, thank you all so so so much!

Begging for Wincest recs

Hi, I've just started reading Dean/Sam fics and am already completely addicted. I found this community and I'm hoping that you guys can rec me some good first time Dean/Sam fics with hot smut that are completed. I would specifically like fics with one or more of the following:

1) Jealousy, Possessiveness, and/or Protectiveness
2) Fuck or Die
3) Lust and/or Love Spell, Curse, Potion, or whatever
4) Boys with Powers
5) Bloodplay and/or Knifeplay
6) Boys as Creatures
7) Boys being Mated or Bound Together, or somehow Connected
8) Boys have to Pretend to be a Couple

Please don't rec me anything that is less than 2,000 words - the longer, the better in my opinion. Also, while I do enjoy pre-series fics, this time I just want during-series fics. No AUs where the boys aren't related and/or aren't hunters, please. Thank you! Please rec me everything you can think of that fits my request, I'm desperate! Oh, and remember, I haven't read any classics as far as I know, so please include those. Thanks!

(To mods - I read the sticky on tags and I think I've got it right this time. Thanks and sorry for any inconveniences.)

Specific Sam College Fic

Hey, I was thinking about writing a Standford era fic, then realized I wasn't sure if I'd thought up the plot or if I was accidentally plagiarizing from something I'd read long ago.

So, does anyone know of a fic where Sam gets packages from Dean while he's at college, and he doesn't tell people who they're from. Eventually Dean shows up, and they're like, 'this is the guy?' and he hasn't said he had a brother, people think it's his boyfriend.

Thank youu.

Gen fics request

I really want to read some well-written awesome fics that others enjoyed :)

1) Non-AU J2 fics with the boys figuring out or disclosing their mutual attraction to each other. UST is always awesome, as is angst.

2) Any h/c low self-esteem fics in which Jared, Jensen, Misha,  Sam, Dean, Cas, or Gabriel feels like he isn't good enough, and another one of the three helps him through it. I'm not really picky about pairings. Self-injury, eating disorders... anything goes. Once again, preferably not AU. I really liked In Mirror Distorted and Indistinct

3) A (possibly shmoopy) story in which one of the boys has to go out of their comfort zone to comfort the other... hugs, cuddling, heart-to-hearts, etc.

4) Inexperienced!Cas... Dean shows Castiel how to get himself off or shows him how to have sex.

5) This one is really general, but any story with great sexual tension that does or does not lead to sex. Long stories filled with awkward moments and awkward boners make me happy :)

Sorry for so many requests! Thanks!

First Kiss

Hey, just wondered if you could rec me some of your favorite sam/dean fics with first kisses. I love fics with a slow build up full of tension with intense, steamy kisses ;) But am happy with any recommendations. :) 
Thanks guys! 

Stealing each other's boyfriends/girlfriends

Hi there! I'm looking for Wincest (Sam/Dean) or J2 stories in which one of them keeps stealing the other one's girlfriends/boyfriends, or simply the people the other one's interested in. It could be like a constant competition between them, and the one losing would be really annoyed and trying to retaliate. But, and this is important, the boys end up together in the end.

Ust between the boys or a love/hate relationship would be a plus. No Dean/Cas, please. Main pairings should be Sam/Dean or Jared/Jensen. Self recs are welcome and encouraged. Any genre or kink is also welcome.

Hope you can help me.

Thank you.

Specific Sam/Dean Fic

I'm looking for a multi-chaptered Wincest fic.

Sam's in love with Dean. He tries to date other guys and Dean gets overprotective. Then John, Dean and Sam go on a hunt and encounter this fairy creature that says she'll help Sam. John finds out about Sam's feelings towards Dean and tells Sam never to tell Dean and Sam goes to Stanford to try and make a new life.

He ends up getting D.W. tattooed on his back and starts a relationship with Jess, but cheats on her to break up with her. Then Dean shows and tells Sam the romantic feelings are mutual. Pretty sure sex with bottom!Sam happens.

Doea anyone recognize this?

Found in the comments!

Long, plotty wincest fics on FF.net

Hey there! You wonderful people have helped me out so many times before, I hope you can help me with this search as well.

I'm looking for long and plotty Wincest stories from the site Fanfiction.net, stories you've loved most, that have stuck with you. I'm fairly new to the site and I'm not very good at sorting through the huge amount of fic there.

I've read the "Full moon, fast cars" verse by cottonmouth and "The Wincester Gospel" by soulfulsam, and I'm searching for anything along those lines. They can be AUs or follow canon, they can feature any theme, kink, genre, I'm not picky. Just let them be long and with a really good, realistic plot.

The main pairing has to be Sam and Dean. No Destiel, gen or het (if there is some het, it should end with the boys together in the end).
Self-recs are welcome and encouraged.

Thank you all in advance! :D

Specific Dean/Gordon fic, general mindcontrolling Wincest search

Hello Storyfinders! I'm hoping you can help me out. (This is only the second request I've ever made, so I hope I do it right!) I read a Gordon/Dean fic a while back, and now I want to reread it, but can't find it. I've tried searching for it, but no luck.

I think it was set after Stanford. Sam joins back up with Dean, only Dean had already been hunting with Gordon for a while. Gordon and Dean were sleeping together, and I believe there was onesided Wincest on Sam's part. In the end Gordon tried to kill Sam but Dean shot him. Does anyone know that fic? I really want to read it again.

I have a second request. Wincest fics where Sam mindcontrols Dean into being with him. (Like Andy's powers.) Accidentally or on purpose, either way, I have a craving for that type of thing. Any level of consent!

Hope you guys can help me out, thanks!