Eso has a huge recs list here, it's mostly Sam/Dean but there's some gen too: http://esorlehcar.livejournal.com/359093.html#cutid1, or this little post here is exclusively gen: http://esorlehcar.livejournal.com/362263.html#cutid1

I generally find that she recs only the best stuff and it's rare that I disagree that something was rec-worthy and some of the fics she points out are absolutely stunning, so you should check her out :)

While I can only say that all the stories I commit to "memories" have met my standards, I am a fairly discerning reader and most of the stories were found through other recs. In my memories I have almost two hundred fics, separated into standalone, wip, and multi-chapter sections, and all with the exception of three are gen.
My gen recs (http://www.livejournal.com/tools/memories.bml?user=estei&authas=estei)

I made a short list of gen recs yesterday. http://sacrilicious.livejournal.com/17094.html

I'd recommend trying P.L. Wynter (wynter rebel on lj)The link to her live journal master story listing is:-
http://wynter-rebel.livejournal.com/16650.html

Her stuff reads like kind of like actual episodes. She's pretty Dean-centric, which suits me ;o) but also writes a very good Sam.

On ff.net you could try Reading's story ~ "Strangers and Angels"

The link I have is http://www.fanfiction.net/s/2748108/1/

It's one of those stories where nothing much happens, at least not in a big action way, but it remains strangely gripping for all that, and the oc's are wonderful.

Both are gen authors.

Hope that helps.

Try just going to www.fanfiction.net. There's no real lists, but the fiction is mostly gen.

Thanks everyone for the fics. I've been over to fanfic.net but I was just wondering if anyone had any good ones over here.Thanks!

Please specify your search in the subject line.