I just reread this one recently and I know I'm going to feel like an idiot when someone finds it, but I cannot remember the title or author at all.


Dean is a hunter priest. One of the first scenes (possibly the very first) has Dean sitting in a pew during Mass and seeing a very tall guy smirking and touching the holy water. The guy starts showing up where Dean is, making it very clear that he wants Dean sexually. He tells Dean his name is Sam and that he's not the hunter Dean thinks he is.

Another scene I remember is Sam trying to convince Dean to have sex with him and Sam says something like "I know you want it" and Dean says "Of course I do" and tells Sam that even though he wants sex he's not going to give in because his vows are more important than getting off.

At the end, Sam reveals that he's Dean's brother, raised by the demons who kidnapped him, and he's there to corrupt Dean.

Anyone know this one?

Found! - Waterstains by leonidaslion.