You've probably read this one

For the Love of Jensen Ackles

http://www.themadslasher.yolasite.com/fortheloveofjensenackles.php

ahaha yeah I've read that one. it's still good though, and kind of where I got the hope to see more like it :) thanks!

not exactly the Ugly Duckling, but more Beauty and the Beast, a wonderful story about Jared, who works in an animal shelter and Jensen, a homeless and lost man. give it a try if you haven't read it yet, master post is here: masterpost Beholder (http://sandymg.livejournal.com/37314.html)

I'm reading this now and oh my god words can't explain how happy it makes me. thanks SO MUCH.

you're welcome! I had to read this story in one go, I just couldn't pry myself away from it!

The Dog Game (http://community.livejournal.com/annie_46fic/28626.html) by annie46

The problem is you make me melt (http://juice817.livejournal.com/200810.html) by juice817

Two perfect examples

Oh yeah I forgot to mention the first one isn't really based on a movie but it fits your premise and the second one is loosely based on the movie She's All That

thanks so much haha I love long stories!

Your Welcome!

If you haven't read them, Lost And Found (http://mediaville.livejournal.com/57649.html) and In A Mirror Distorted And Indistinct (http://felisblanco.livejournal.com/672910.html) are both fantastic and kind of fit your request.

In addition, since you liked the above poster's rec of Beholder, you will probably also like In From The Cold (http://ladyjanelly.livejournal.com/tag/homeless%20jensen).

Happy reading! :)
~Malinda

I've not read any of those and I think I love you.