Hi,

This community is making me want to read stories that of course I can't seem to find.

Summary:
Dean is stubborn and doesn't believe he turned a male incubus in the form of his fantasy human. He is also saying he isn't gay, until he finally gives up and keeps having sex, embarassing Sam and John with scenes.

The incubus turned human eventually goes back to his female 'owner' who used him for sex and gives back everything he owns and goes back to Dean.

Fic found: link in comments

Does it ring a bell to anyone?

I would love to read it again.

Eve
aka
spikewil