I've been looking for this J2-AU for awhile now, and remebered that y'all are here to give me a helping hand.

Story: Jared and Jensen are from a small town. Jared left for some reason but is now back as a new Sheriff. His first case in town turns out to be his old secret fling, Jensen. Jensen is actual in custody of the sheriff's department when Jared arrives back in town. Jared has the unhappy job of being the first to question Jensen about the crime.

Other characters: Chad was another sheriff, and Jensen's little sister was in this story, and was a very protective spitfire. I even think Chris was in it as well.

Please help me find this story.