http://tornknees.livejournal.com/22453.html

it has Sam and Dean settling down. It's not very long, less than 5,000 words, but it's supposed to be a verse, so it should get longer.

Thank you so much!

The first one that popped in my head is a spn/j2 bb from earlier this year...

Like a Fish Out of Water by nyxocity (word count 59k)
AU after Plucky Pennywhistle's Magical Menagerie. During the final battle with the Leviathans, God finally makes an appearance and deigns to intervene. After granting Sam and Dean a few final requests, he 'packs his bags' and takes everything supernatural in existence with him. Left with nothing to hunt, Sam talks a reluctant Dean into settling down in a small town outside of Sioux Falls. Sam seems to want them live a normal kind of life, but between the ridiculous estate sale Sam bought to furnish the house, the arrival of a very human Castiel who's overwhelmed by human emotions, and their quirky, invasive neighbors, it's anything but. Dean's having a difficult time adjusting, convinced everything couldn't be more abnormal until Sam reveals exactly what kind of life he wants to have with Dean. Dean can't deny the part of him that wants it--but can he accept it?
http://nyxocity.livejournal.com/209080.html

then...

A Life Most Ordinary by sonofabiscuit77 (word count 60k) an awesome au you might like.
Sam and Dean Winchester are two ordinary brothers living ordinary, small-town lives. Okay, so maybe having a mother who was brutally murdered by one of America’s most notorious serial killers and a father who needs 6 different kinds of medication to get out of bed in the morning is not that ordinary, but the rest of their problems: relationship failures and job disappointments, too many bills and too much overtime, and Dean’s two kids, 9 year-old Jonah with his disturbing passion for the music of Lady Gaga and 6-year old Simon with his severe hearing loss, well they’re entirely ordinary... The only thing extraordinary about Sam and Dean is this: the story of how they fell in love and how they learned to cope in such an ordinary world with such an extraordinary love.
http://sonofabiscuit77.livejournal.com/30497.html

This is the Place by mistyzeo (word count 24k)
Lucifer's cage isn't built for Lucifer's vessel, and Sam is ejected from Hell before Dean leaves Stull Cemetery in Lawrence. But it's been hours for Dean, and days for Sam, and Sam didn't get out before the demons got their barbs into him. Dean's done fighting, and all he wants now is to keep Sam safe, and damn the consequences. When Bobby tells them they'd better lay low for a while, Dean takes the opportunity to let his brother rest and heal. And maybe figure out what Sam's wanted all his life, and what Dean needs to be happy. (AU for the end of 5x22 and beyond)
http://mistyzeo.livejournal.com/59377.html

Out Of the Night That Covers Me by mickeym (word count: 23k)
The apocalypse was stopped at the eleventh hour, and Lucifer was forced back into his cage. Sam and Dean survived, but now they have to learn how to deal with the loss and destruction, and figure out how to move forward. But how do you move forward when you're mired in the past, and caught up in a web of rage and pain?
http://mickeym.livejournal.com/1271207.html

grrr, d**n lj word limit!

Pie In The Sky by flawedamythyst (word count 18,565)
This was originally a bit of a challenge to myself to write curtain!fic, which is one of the clichés I love and which I hadn't written yet. You know how I love clichés, right? Somehow, it ended up a whole lot longer than I was expecting and with a lot more pie. A LOT more pie. I started to write it mid-way through season 4, so the myth-arc-y stuff is a bit out-of-date, but that's not really the main point of this anyway. Mainly, it's all about the domestic schmoop.
http://flawedamythyst.livejournal.com/357746.html

Renovation series by de_nugis (word count 14,719)
each part has a summary.
http://archiveofourown.org/series/10459

Wherever We're Together That's My Home by shannon_doll (word count 6777)
It's the small town gigs that keep them going - once a hunter always a hunter. A month of domestic bliss would do them well, and he's pretty sure Sam would agree to pancakes in the morning.
http://shannon-doll.livejournal.com/85869.html

Long Lay The World by setissma (word count 5300)
Dean gives Sam a house for Christmas. THIS IS ALL THE SUMMARY YOU NEED.
(But just in case you need more summary, this fic includes a) a werewolf b) Chicago c) handyman!Dean d) total girl!Sam e) a lot of sex f) CHRISTMAS g) pancakes and bacon.)
http://setissma.livejournal.com/542405.html

The King of Imperfection Takes Back the Prince of Mistakes by britomart_is (word count 3600)
a fairy tale
http://britomart-is.livejournal.com/122328.html

The Piper by gretazreta (word count 44,500)
They've left hunting behind and settled down to small town life, but it's not easy. There's a plague of rats in the wheat-field and the town's in crisis. It's probably not their kind of gig, but that won't stop Dean from getting to the bottom of it, even if it means burning their house down in the process. Sam's memory is full of holes. He's having dreams, another thing he can't talk to Dean about, and he can't shake the feeling that Dean's not telling him everything that's happened.
http://gretazreta.livejournal.com/125116.html

Life As We Know It by sevenfists (word count 13,500)
Our boys buy curtains and fall in love.
http://sevenfists.livejournal.com/113120.html

Oh lawd, THANK YOU!!!

To Honour Losses by Lelleigh http://archive.worldofslash.com/viewstory.php?sid=31&ageconsent=ok&warning=4
Word count: 433207

Summary: Sam finds out that Dean had ambitions, that he once wanted and came close to being normal. Bobby gives them a case where Dean’s dreams may finally come true

Although technically it's a WIP (and looks like it'll stay that way) the story finishes at a natural stopping place. You'll have to register to see it.