Sam is in love with Dean, but Dean has no idea. A siren is luring guys like Sam who feel lost/lonely to their deaths. Details under the cut.



Sam is about to walk into the ocean and drown himself due to the pull of the siren. Dean stops him and forces Sam to tell him what is wrong. Dean realizes what he has to do to save Sam even though he isn't in love with Sam, he loves Sam but isn't in love with him. He tells Sam he feels the same, but Sam doesn't believe him. Dean starts kissing Sam and is thankful he is able to get aroused, they have sex. Story goes on for a while with Sam and Dean having a relationship and hunting the siren, and Dean keeping Sam safe from the siren. They end up killing the siren. Dean tells Sam they should take a break. Of course Sam realizes what Dean did and shuts down and becomes even sadder. Dean realizes that what he had with Sam was good, and realizes he really is in love with Sam. Dean convinces Sam that he is in love with him, and happily ever after ensues.



Apparently I forgot to bookmark this or lost it somehow. I don't remember the author, but am pretty sure it was on LJ. Can anyone point me to this story?

Found. Mermaid Verse by sleepypercy