I don´t know if this what you looking for, but...

3#
Bend Over Boyfriend http://sdwbf.livejournal.com/5874.html (http://sdwbf.livejournal.com/5874.html)

2#
I´m No Angel http://archiveofourown.org/works/185187 (http://archiveofourown.org/works/185187) (dark!)

Thanks!

This is one of my favorite fics ever because it's cute and the virginity is the focus of the fic/Dean gets in trouble because of it on a case: The Rules Remain a Mystery by joyfulgirl41 (http://joyfulgirl41.livejournal.com/296133.html)

This one I'll give a warning for underage Sam at 15, though Sam's certainly not the inexperienced one and Sam's the aggressor: Something to Talk About by albydarned (http://omg-fics.livejournal.com/22004.html)

Different Flavors by selecasharp (http://teashopmuses.livejournal.com/9874.html): Dean starts teasing Sam about being a prude, but really Dean's the more vanilla of the two, so Sam shows him some new things.

A fic that kinda borders on your request is Sorta-Virgin Sacrifice by anne-higgins (http://anne-higgins.livejournal.com/4845.html): Turns out virginity is a state of mind and some demons aren't as picky as others.

Bonus Fic Like a Virgin by leonidaslion (http://archiveofourown.org/works/181718). Dean isn't physically a virgin at all, but has been cursed to be one mentally. Very adorable with lots of blushing and fun.

I'll also warn that, while none of these are non-con, there are dub-con elements to a few because of curses, though none of it is violent and everyone ends up having fun.

EDIT: Oops, Different Flavors was by selecasharp, not pixymisa.

Edited 2013-11-15 12:40 am (UTC)

Thank you!!!