I think the story is called "Starting Over" Jared is in a custody battle for his son, who was abused by his ex's boyfriend, which left Jared's son mute. He meets Jensen and has an instant attraction to the other man. Jensen has reservations about pursuing a relationship. Chad Michael Murray and James Lafferty are a couple in the story. Jensen has a twin brother named Dean who is in a relationship with Misha in the story as well.