I really really miss season 1/2 of SPN. I mean the other seasons aren't bad and I do love season 9 even if people have mixed feelings on this one but there's just that horror movie atmosphere that season 1 and 2 had that can't be replaced.

And since it looks a lot like the SPN writers seem to really like this demon/angel plot line, I've found myself having to rely on fanfic to get my 'fix'. And I'm having some trouble wading through all these romance AU stories to find the more traditional case stories, and even rarer, ones that are more genuinely classified horror. Like you know, 'Bloody Mary', 'Bugs', 'Scarecrow'...the likes.

It'd be awesome if anyone could rec any stories dealing with legends, crossover with horror movies even. I'll take anything that's in the horror genre. Old or new. I wouldn't mind seeing a story about 'Slender Man' (that'd be pretty interesting honestly) or 'Sand Man'. Preferably I don't want overly complicated plots with angels/demons. Just some genuine horror. Characters I don't mind seeing: Dean, Sam, John, Bobby, Castiel

Also while I don't mind death!fics, I prefer to avoid them.