I found this still on line: https://www.fanfiction.net/s/8738988/1/Exonerated

Thank you, I saw that link already. Sadly, when you click through the chapters it's all author's notes :(

No worries, though! I was able to find it in the end :)

Is this the second one? https://archiveofourown.org/works/10024229

I found this note on CynicalModerate's fanfiction.net profile (at https://www.fanfiction.net/u/237601/CynicalModerate):
Several stories have been removed: Office: Arbor Day, SPN AU: Will We Make It?, SPN AU: The Lunatic Parade, SPN/Hellraiser: Exquisite Agony, and SPN AU: Act of the Inevitable. This is simply because I cannot think of how to continue them at this time. They have been saved, so I could possibly repost them at some point in the future. At this time, though, I cannot foresee myself doing that. At most, I will pursue occasional one-shots and new stories when the mood takes me.

Yeah, I saw that message. It's been like that for few years already if I'm not mistaken. I just hoped someone saved it before the author removed :)

Wayback Machine has Exonerated:)

https://web.archive.org/web/20150822190920/http://archiveofourown.org/works/827927?view_full_work=true

Thank you! I always try wayback machine but I guess I still haven't gotten a hand of it because I didn't get any results.